We match you with mondy for school
Welcome Guest Home | Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

Difference between universities? Options
Miss
Posted: Thursday, April 24, 2008 8:40:53 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/24/2008
Posts: 285
Location: mississauga
So um, is there a huge difference between universities in general? I'm finding that they start to seem very similar after a while, well at least the big ones with each other, and the small ones with each other... opinions?

"My parents live in Ohio; I live in the moment." -himym.
Stringer
Posted: Thursday, April 24, 2008 9:32:26 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 1,471
Location: Wilfrid Laurier University
It's generally the same thing. I've been to quite a few and most of the differences are minor, at least in terms of partying.

-Stringer
mynameismattgotmlgo
Posted: Friday, April 25, 2008 1:33:30 AM
Rank: Student Council
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 448
Location: Sarnia
I couldn't agree more.

Honours BMSc Double Major in Physiology and Medical Science UWO '09
heythereb
Posted: Friday, April 25, 2008 8:31:50 PM
Rank: Student Council
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/7/2008
Posts: 330
Location: Toronto
That's pretty much true. I think that there are 3 "types" of univesities, determined largely by reputation or at least preception by students.

Tier 1 - the top univesities - McGill, UofT, Queen's, UBC

Tier 2 - middle - Guelph, Waterloo, McMaster (although it does have some strong programs), UWO (again, Tier 1 or 2, depends if you look at it from a "party school/attracts idiots" or "really good programs, like Med Sci")

Tier 3 - bottom - Carleton (definitely encouraged by the "we're giving money away" scholarships), Brock

I am talking about perceptions gained by listening to students at *my* high school, so this list isn't set in stone, and I'm not trying to diss anyone's university, etc.

I think that unless you're going for a specific program (Health Science, for ex) that's exclusive to one university, a lot of them will offer the same courses for any one program. A big thing that varies, though, is location and school size. So in a big city, you'd probably have more opportunities to intern, volunteer at a variety of orgs, etc. But if you're at a big school that attracts lots of excellent students, you'd be competing with a lot of people for merit awards, RA positions, and internship placements.

McGill Arts '12
ameko
Posted: Saturday, May 03, 2008 3:02:31 PM
Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/27/2008
Posts: 60
Location: Tdot
^ agree with above poster

but i do know somene that graduated from brock (in accoutning program) and have even passed the CA exam thing and is now working for a big firm
Bassoony
Posted: Sunday, May 04, 2008 12:43:37 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/6/2008
Posts: 81
Location: Waterloo
Someone who graduates from a "lower rated" school and works really hard still has a good chance of getting a job over someone from a "higher ranked" school and has never actually applied themself to their studies.
rose89
Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 7:54:23 AM
Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 5/17/2008
Posts: 7
Location: U.A.E.
heythereb wrote:
That's pretty much true. I think that there are 3 "types" of univesities, determined largely by reputation or at least preception by students.

Tier 1 - the top univesities - McGill, UofT, Queen's, UBC

Tier 2 - middle - Guelph, Waterloo, McMaster (although it does have some strong programs), UWO (again, Tier 1 or 2, depends if you look at it from a "party school/attracts idiots" or "really good programs, like Med Sci")

Tier 3 - bottom - Carleton (definitely encouraged by the "we're giving money away" scholarships), Brock

I am talking about perceptions gained by listening to students at *my* high school, so this list isn't set in stone, and I'm not trying to diss anyone's university, etc.

I think that unless you're going for a specific program (Health Science, for ex) that's exclusive to one university, a lot of them will offer the same courses for any one program. A big thing that varies, though, is location and school size. So in a big city, you'd probably have more opportunities to intern, volunteer at a variety of orgs, etc. But if you're at a big school that attracts lots of excellent students, you'd be competing with a lot of people for merit awards, RA positions, and internship placements.


Hey,
I'm trying to decide between Life Sciences at U of T and McMaster.
I've been offered places at both.
I have no idea where it would be better to go.
As in which has the better program, better professors, better chance of getting into medschool etc.
ESPECIALLY which gives you a better shot at MedSchool.
You sound like someone who has an idea of what each entail.
I'm not asking for the cold hard facts.
I just need an insiders opinion of which is better.
Whats the word of mouth?

Like I hear that McMaster have an amazing Health Sciences Program and I missed the deadline for that but, IF I chose to go to McMaster I intend to switch programs at the earliest convenience. Anyway, I hear that a VERY large amount of people graduating from the McMaster Health Science program get into MedSchool afterwards.
However I also HEAR that U of T has more opportunities to volunteer and get involved with your degree. I also hear they have better professors. AND the University is more recognized Internationally.
So I'm just wondering.
I mean I don't live in Canada I have no idea what each school involves. I've seen the campuses but thats about it...
Does anyone know what the student life is like in each University?
I mean people say that if you go down the MedSchool road eliminate all social life, but yeah, just asking...

Thanks
Redrose27
Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 3:51:53 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 1,197
Hmmm see from my parents' side I keep hearing the 'most universities are the same and the degrees will get you to the same place' speech but from people that are in the different programs I sometimes hear things that are quite different.

For instance, my parents say that trying to pursue an arts/science degree at UW or Laurier would give me the same knowledge and degree weight as doing that same degree in Western Ontario or Queens, except that at Western I'd be paying about $4000 extra each term for the residence and meal plans (they cost more but western also has offered me more scholarships so that would make up some of the difference). The program I got into at Western is also a specialized one which, yes would give me an extra workload, but at the same time is prestigious and gives lots of very good opportunities (the SE module) whereas the only real equivalent i've got at UW is KI which is a very new degree (brand new) and I don't know whether it would hold the same value as the regular BSc or BMSc and SE designation i'd be getting at Western. I've got a very strong pull for me to stay at home, be it for a fifth year or to go to a local university, but the more I read about Western the more I'd like to go (Queen's is another university that I'd like to attend but I didn't send in an application and it would generalyl be more expensive than UWO anyway, minus the SE program, so I'd choose western over queen's in this case). I'm wondering if I'm making a mistake though in this process--would an arts and science degree from UWO be worth the extra 16 000 (or more) at the end of the four years? Are the downsides of the SE program (extensive workload in addition to the regular classes you take) worth the experience you get (and, again, the money)? OR am I just looking at it from the grass is greener on the other side sort of lens, where I view UWO and SE as being this terrific school with terrific facilities and excellent student life (okay the last one i know western is well known for) and am i wasting my money in the process? While staying next year at home would be an almost certainty if i stayed local, there is a possibility of me moving out in my upper years if i go to a local uni so I'd end up paying for food and residence anyway most likely if i went to a local one, so the financial difference would be decreased in that regard.

If you were in my situation, and had the option of saving potentially almost 20 000 by going to a university that's local and staying home rather than going to another university that is perhaps better known for those programs, would you do it?

Another part of me is being pulled in the direction of knowing that when i'm in my thirties and buying a house, that extra 16 or 20 000 that seemed so much to me at 17 will look like nothing, and that in the long run, my university experience and the life value of moving out on my own and going to another city would be worth the extra several thousand a year (and that on the switch side if i had gone to an american university i'd be paying double that just for one year's tuition).

I've got a friend who goes to mcgill now, an exceptionally bright guy, and he says that in the first few months he did regret not going to a local university but opinions and experiences change and after you adjust the experiences you'd have from an entirely new city and new people and living on your own is worth it, but that there were some downsides to it as well.

On the other hand i've got a sister who is currently in uw for science who says that you can take advantage of a lot of opportunities here regardless and still be successful, enriched, and challenged (and there's the co op option as well), but at the same time a part of her wishes she accepted her health science offer at Mac back when she was in high school because it was such a more prestigious program (and she ended up moving out on her own after year one anyway so she spent money on residence here). So there are conflicting opinions and views that i'm getting even from the same person.
Redrose27
Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 8:12:57 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 1,197
any replies?
Stringer
Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 8:17:20 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 1,471
Location: Wilfrid Laurier University
In terms of job prospects, there will be little difference between an arts or science degree from WLU or Western. Same with grad school, etc.

What will be different is how you enjoy your time. If you are set on Western, go there. If you go to WLU and your heart is not there you will likely regret it.

As for the money issue, I wouldn't worry too much about that $16,000 if you can still afford school. Obviously if you can't afford to go to Western, then don't go, but if you can in the long-run that amount of money is nothing.

By the nature of your post it sounds like Western is the place you want to be. If that's true, just go!

-Stringer
heythereb
Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 8:26:07 PM
Rank: Student Council
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/7/2008
Posts: 330
Location: Toronto

I only know what I've heard, and I'm by no means an insider.

But from what I understand, expect to work HARD and still receive subpar marks at U of T, at least in first year. Classes go up to 1000 for some freshman science courses, and you have to compete with those people for marks. So "medschool hopeful no social life" is true in that sense at U of T. McMaster isn't any easier, but the classes are probably smaller.

From what I understand, the programs themselves aren't to different. Since U of T is bigger, you might have more course options, but if you manage to transfer to Health Sci at McMaster, I think the courses trump U of T lifesci. HSc covers a lot of stuff you'll have to study in med school, like pathology of organ tissues, anatomy etc. Plus I heard that it teaches you to "reason" about what sort of disease someone has based on their symptoms. So that's a good thing to be able to do before you go to med school

In terms of social life, U of T is kind of a commuter school. I know that the 10+ people I know who are going to U of T will be living at home. But I heard that rez is lots of fun. Plus the residences are right downtown, which can either be awesome or a big distraction.

McMaster is more rez-oriented. And while Hamilton is a smaller city, you can definitely find lots of opportunities to volunteer in hospitals/clinics. But if you're serious about med school, I would also think about other places to volunteer, since basically every med school hopeful will do a stint in a hospital. So look for a homeless shelter, or a rehab center - these also show your "compassion" toward the sick and needy.

Hope that helps a bit.

McGill Arts '12
Miss
Posted: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 9:36:02 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/24/2008
Posts: 285
Location: mississauga
I don't know how easily you can transfer into health sci, considering their selectiveness from applicants entering at the high school level (if you've got teh grades though, go for it!) And yes, it's true that health sci students tend to get into med school, but that's probably because of their pre-existing work habits (considering that you need what, a 95+ average to get in? you need a good work ethic right?). That being said, the program itself is easier than the normal life sci, from what I hear, because it is much more focused on the human-interaction aspect of being a doctor.

However, u of t is VERY competitive, I know some people who were told the wrong classrooms by hyper-competitive students, had their notes stolen, etc, although I highly doubt this is an everyday thing. Either way, both schools are based on rankings I believe, so they will both entail a competitive environment. They both do have excellent programs however, and resources when it comes to health/life sci.

Good luck with your choice, and sorry for the pseudo-statistics lol smile

"My parents live in Ohio; I live in the moment." -himym.


Forum Jump

Powered by Yet Another Forum.net
Copyright © 2003-2006 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 1998-2008 studentawards.com & boursetudes.com - Studentawards Inc. All rights reserved.