We match you with mondy for school
Welcome Guest Home | Search | Active Topics | Members | Log In | Register

The borrower is slave to the lender. Options
nasir jones
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 10:50:10 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/10/2008
Posts: 264
This is what the bible has to say about loans:

The rich rule over the poor,
and the borrower is servant to the lender

- Proverbs 22:7

why dont you people work a few years to be able to afford your tuition rather than taking ridiculous ammounts of loans from banks and institutions? most of you will never pay it off...when you do, you will have borrowed more, and you will have been enslaved.

Remember kids, you can not borrow to get out of debt, so when you have $60,000 piled up, do not consolidate it, your interest (usury) rate will be higher.

You can either enjoy your indebted life or make the money yourself and pay cash, its up to you.
Stringer
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 10:56:05 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 1,711
Location: Wilfrid Laurier University
nasir jones wrote:
This is what the bible has to say about loans:

The rich rule over the poor,
and the borrower is servant to the lender

- Proverbs 22:7

why dont you people work a few years to be able to afford your tuition rather than taking ridiculous ammounts of loans from banks and institutions? most of you will never pay it off...when you do, you will have borrowed more, and you will have been enslaved.

Remember kids, you can not borrow to get out of debt, so when you have $60,000 piled up, do not consolidate it, your interest (usury) rate will be higher.

You can either enjoy your indebted life or make the money yourself and pay cash, its up to you.


There is good debt and bad debt.

Student loans are good debt. A mortgage is a good debt.

Bad debt is consuming more than you can afford.

You would be much better off financially getting your degree sooner in some debt than waiting a few years to save up enough money. Your salary is likely going to go up by a big percentage when you have a degree, which would easily cover the tiny interest costs of student loans.

Also, why would I take any advice from the Bible, let alone financial advice?

-Stringer
nasir jones
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 10:57:45 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/10/2008
Posts: 264
Stringer wrote:
nasir jones wrote:
This is what the bible has to say about loans:

The rich rule over the poor,
and the borrower is servant to the lender

- Proverbs 22:7

why dont you people work a few years to be able to afford your tuition rather than taking ridiculous ammounts of loans from banks and institutions? most of you will never pay it off...when you do, you will have borrowed more, and you will have been enslaved.

Remember kids, you can not borrow to get out of debt, so when you have $60,000 piled up, do not consolidate it, your interest (usury) rate will be higher.

You can either enjoy your indebted life or make the money yourself and pay cash, its up to you.


There is good debt and bad debt.

Student loans are good debt. A mortgage is a good debt.

Bad debt is consuming more than you can afford.

You would be much better off financially getting your degree sooner in some debt than waiting a few years to save up enough money. Your salary is likely going to go up by a big percentage when you have a degree, which would easily cover the tiny interest costs of student loans.

Also, why would I take any advice from the Bible, let alone financial advice?


lol "good" debt, listen to yourself calling interest rate low...

1. Any interest rate is bad
2. They want you to beleive that it is "good" debt
3. Student loans are for suckers, ask any banker, oh wait...they wont tell you that
Stringer
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 11:03:53 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 1,711
Location: Wilfrid Laurier University
nasir jones wrote:
Stringer wrote:
nasir jones wrote:
This is what the bible has to say about loans:

The rich rule over the poor,
and the borrower is servant to the lender

- Proverbs 22:7

why dont you people work a few years to be able to afford your tuition rather than taking ridiculous ammounts of loans from banks and institutions? most of you will never pay it off...when you do, you will have borrowed more, and you will have been enslaved.

Remember kids, you can not borrow to get out of debt, so when you have $60,000 piled up, do not consolidate it, your interest (usury) rate will be higher.

You can either enjoy your indebted life or make the money yourself and pay cash, its up to you.


There is good debt and bad debt.

Student loans are good debt. A mortgage is a good debt.

Bad debt is consuming more than you can afford.

You would be much better off financially getting your degree sooner in some debt than waiting a few years to save up enough money. Your salary is likely going to go up by a big percentage when you have a degree, which would easily cover the tiny interest costs of student loans.

Also, why would I take any advice from the Bible, let alone financial advice?


lol "good" debt, listen to yourself calling interest rate low...

1. Any interest rate is bad
2. They want you to beleive that it is "good" debt
3. Student loans are for suckers, ask any banker, oh wait...they wont tell you that


You clearly have no idea about how finance works.

Most students get loans from the government. They charge no interest until the student graduates. That is FREE MONEY. You would be an idiot not to take advantage of that offer.

Why would you work a low-paying job for a few years? Graduate, and get a job that pays 100%+ more than you would make without a degree. No interest rate in the world would make it better to work before going to university.

If I'm getting charged 5% interest per year on a loan, but making 10% per year with that money, how is that bad? You are about as short-sighted as a 6th grader when it comes to finance.

-Stringer
bigbadsheep
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 11:05:29 PM

Rank: Valedictorian
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 538
Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea. Like Stringer said, why am I going to the Bible for financial advice, I barely go for spiritual advice as it is. Loans that you can pay off help build your credit rating, which makes a whole lot more things in life easier. Buying a house, car, appliances and other major purchases are made easier. Listen to yourself, you sound like one of those end of the world/ conspiracy theorists. And your post about how you will never pay off your loan is bogus. Some people, especially ones that do co-op are able to pay off their loan even before they leave school, so stop flaming the boards with nonsense.

UWO '12 Social Science
nasir jones
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 11:09:32 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/10/2008
Posts: 264
bigbadsheep wrote:
Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea. Like Stringer said, why am I going to the Bible for financial advice, I barely go for spiritual advice as it is. Loans that you can pay off help build your credit rating, which makes a whole lot more things in life easier. Buying a house, car, appliances and other major purchases are made easier. Listen to yourself, you sound like one of those end of the world/ conspiracy theorists. And your post about how you will never pay off your loan is bogus. Some people, especially ones that do co-op are able to pay off their loan even before they leave school, so stop flaming the boards with nonsense.


yeah its very easy to end up paying more than 100% of the original value of a house, car appliance and "major" purchases with your pathetic credit card, enjoy your life of being used (also you stringer). You guys will keep taking loans for fun and getting yourselfs raped by interest
bigbadsheep
Posted: Thursday, April 10, 2008 11:15:21 PM

Rank: Valedictorian
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 538
nasir jones wrote:
bigbadsheep wrote:
Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea. Like Stringer said, why am I going to the Bible for financial advice, I barely go for spiritual advice as it is. Loans that you can pay off help build your credit rating, which makes a whole lot more things in life easier. Buying a house, car, appliances and other major purchases are made easier. Listen to yourself, you sound like one of those end of the world/ conspiracy theorists. And your post about how you will never pay off your loan is bogus. Some people, especially ones that do co-op are able to pay off their loan even before they leave school, so stop flaming the boards with nonsense.


yeah its very easy to end up paying more than 100% of the original value of a house, car appliance and "major" purchases with your pathetic credit card, enjoy your life of being used (also you stringer). You guys will keep taking loans for fun and getting yourselfs raped by interest


Oh yeah, me and Stringer are the only two idiots in the world who believe credit has value. Man we must be living under a rock. You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if you default on a payment right? So pay your bills, and enjoy what you buy instead of wasting away half your paychecks in wasteless expenditure such as rent opposed to a mortgage, paying full price in cash instead of taking advantage of payment options etc.

UWO '12 Social Science
snapicus
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 10:40:40 AM
Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 4/15/2008
Posts: 4
Location: Nashville, TN USA
The vast majority of people agree that debt is a tool that can be used to create leverage and build wealth. The vast majority of people are also broke. I don't find this to be a coincidence.

I can only speak from my experience when I say that I wish I had not borrowed my way through school. If I had paid my own way with money I had earned, my choices in major, school, and career path would have been much smarter. I wouldn't have had to go to school a second time to follow my true path, and I wouldn't be staring down the barrel of all this debt.

I reccomend reading the book The Millionaire Next Door, by Thomas Stanley. One trait that they found among most wealthy people was an aversion to borrowing of all kinds. While there were exceptions, the trend was toward using cash.

Nasir, you are in the minority, but you are right. When your income is tied up in payments, it is much more difficult to build wealth. Dunn & Bradstreet did a study that shows that when people buy things on credit, they end up spending 12-18% more than when they pay cash. Add interest on top of that and it's easy to see how many people "nickel and dime" themselves out of retiring wealthy.

bigbadsheep and stringer, you guys are intelligent, and I once thought as you did. On paper, your arguments are very sound (they were once mine too), but I've found that personal finance is less about math and more about behavior. I'm currently paying off my debts and have resolved not to borrow anymore. I find that I have been a better businessman and have made smarter decisions since changing to a cash-based mindset. I hope you'll consider these points and possibly reevaluate what you've been told about debt.

In the words of a great teacher, Dave Ramsey "Broke is normal. Be Wierd." smile
Kaylya
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 11:16:29 AM

Rank: Student Body Vice-President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 997
Location: Ottawa
bigbadsheep wrote:

Oh yeah, me and Stringer are the only two idiots in the world who believe credit has value. Man we must be living under a rock. You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if you default on a payment right? So pay your bills, and enjoy what you buy instead of wasting away half your paychecks in wasteless expenditure such as rent opposed to a mortgage, paying full price in cash instead of taking advantage of payment options etc.


I can assure you that interest is always there for a mortgage, as well as most loans, and credit cards unless you pay them in full every month. There are sometimes deals that let you put off paying with "no interest for a year", but very often you do ultimately end up paying more ("3% administrative charge"), and then you really do need to know what happens should you miss a payment for whatever reason, because it might then be downright punitive.

Now, I don't want to say it never makes sense to go for these options. I personally use my credit card a lot so I can have my money sitting in my savings account earning interest longer. If I have the money to buy a car today, and they will offer me 0% or 1% interest on a financing deal over a year, it may make sense to keep my money earning interest and pay for the car over the course of a year. But they might also offer me a better price on the car if I pay them today. And then most people when they are entering into these deals don't have the money right then.

You are usually going to be better off putting $100 per month for a year into a savings account (net gain with ING's current rates: $21.67 in interest) to save up for that fancy new $1200 TV than you are buying it today and paying it + 3% administrative charge ($36 on a $1200 TV) off over a year.

snapicus
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 11:40:32 AM
Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 4/15/2008
Posts: 4
Location: Nashville, TN USA
Well stated, Kaylya. It's really important to think about how we're spending our money, rather than just running out and buying stuff.

I'd like to add a couple things, just to consider.

One thing to bear in mind is that 0% financing is only on new cars (and only happens on about 20% of the deals done, according to consumer reports), which lose a ton of value as soon as you drive them off the lot. So if you're getting 0% interest on a $24,000 car that loses $5,000 in value as soon as you take posession of it, you're still not coming out ahead. Also, the 0% financing is one of the factors in the negotiation, so if you want the low interest rate, they usually have you concede on price, so you pay more.

The "0% for 90 days" or 6 months or whatever deals are often at 18% or more interest, which gets backdated to the day of purchase if you don't pay it off completely before the due date. Heaven forbid your check gets "lost in the mail" or some idiot in a cube at the finance company shreds the check or lets it sit on his desk for a few days past the due date. Arguing with them if that happens could end up being your new hobby. If you pay cash for things, and I mean real cash, bills in your hand money, you can often negotiate better deals on the showroom floor. So that $1200 TV you might be able to get for $1000 by paying cash "on the barrel". In those cases, 90 days is definitely not the "same as cash."

Take it for what it's worth, but I find I often have the upper hand when I have money that I've saved up for things. It also helps me maintain my "walk-away" power, since I'm not always sure I'd rather have that TV than a big pile of cash I've worked so hard for.
tjmontario
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 12:17:05 PM
Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/23/2008
Posts: 26
Location: Ontario
bigbadsheep wrote:
nasir jones wrote:
bigbadsheep wrote:
Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea. Like Stringer said, why am I going to the Bible for financial advice, I barely go for spiritual advice as it is. Loans that you can pay off help build your credit rating, which makes a whole lot more things in life easier. Buying a house, car, appliances and other major purchases are made easier. Listen to yourself, you sound like one of those end of the world/ conspiracy theorists. And your post about how you will never pay off your loan is bogus. Some people, especially ones that do co-op are able to pay off their loan even before they leave school, so stop flaming the boards with nonsense.


yeah its very easy to end up paying more than 100% of the original value of a house, car appliance and "major" purchases with your pathetic credit card, enjoy your life of being used (also you stringer). You guys will keep taking loans for fun and getting yourselfs raped by interest


Oh yeah, me and Stringer are the only two idiots in the world who believe credit has value. Man we must be living under a rock. You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if you default on a payment right? So pay your bills, and enjoy what you buy instead of wasting away half your paychecks in wasteless expenditure such as rent opposed to a mortgage, paying full price in cash instead of taking advantage of payment options etc.


Where to begin....roll eyes

"Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea."

Yes, yes it is a bad idea. Unless you like to give your hard earned money away.

"Buying a house, car, appliances, and other major purchases are made easier."

Anyone who buys any major purchase other than a house on credit is setting themself up for financial ruin.

"You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if your default on a payment right?"

No, no it doesn't. On most things interest starts the day after your next payment is due if you still have a balance owing. And on a lot of loans interest is factored into your monthly payments to begin with.

"Wasting away half your paychecks in wasteless expenditure such as rent opposed to a mortgage, paying full price in cash instead of taking advantage or payment options"

You are aware that a lot of stores give a discount for people that pay with cash right? They just don't advertise it. Stores lose money when people use credit cards(unless it is their own store credit card). Also, there are many other advantages to saving up and paying with cash rather than credit or "payment plans".

Example:

You want to buy a a nice big lcd t.v. worth $2000.00 and you have nothing in the bank to put towards it and can only afford 84.00/month to go towards the t.v., whether you save up for it or put it on credit. If you put it on credit you estimate it will take 2 years to pay it off in full. And your credit card charges 18.5% annual interest.

Now, you have a decision, either save up the money for that t.v. or put it on credit. Lets look at how that works out in the long run for each option.

Cash option:


You put $84.00/month into a term savings account earning 3.3% interest compounded daily and paid monthly you would have $1997.06 in your account for the tv after 2 years. Where $65.06 is interest EARNED. So you are actually only paying around $1935.00 for the t.v. And maybe much less depending on if the store offers a cash discount.

Credit option:


You take the plunge and put the t.v. on the credit card which charges 18.5% annual interest compounded monthly and you make $84.00/month payments until it is paid off. It will take you 30 months to pay off the balance, total amount paid $2511.35. That is $511.35 in interest. Now what if you decided to put the t.v. on a store credit card, lets say, FutureShop, which charges a disgusting 28.8% annual interest, while still making the $84.00/month payments, it would take you 36 months to pay off, total paid $3001.19, with $1001.19 in interest.

So...

Cash = $1935.00(or less) paid for a $2000.00 tv in two years.

Credit card at 18.5% = $2511.35 paid for a $2000.00 t.v.

Store credit card at 28.8% = $3001.19 paid for a $2000.00 t.v.

What else is there to say? lol..
snapicus
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 12:36:38 PM
Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 4/15/2008
Posts: 4
Location: Nashville, TN USA
Many stores' credit card divisions are a larger profit center than the retail stores themselves. This was especially the case with Sears, who founded Discover. When Sears ran into financial trouble a few years back, they sold off Discover and made a huge profit.
bigbadsheep
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 2:27:36 PM

Rank: Valedictorian
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 538
tjmontario wrote:
bigbadsheep wrote:
nasir jones wrote:
bigbadsheep wrote:
Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea. Like Stringer said, why am I going to the Bible for financial advice, I barely go for spiritual advice as it is. Loans that you can pay off help build your credit rating, which makes a whole lot more things in life easier. Buying a house, car, appliances and other major purchases are made easier. Listen to yourself, you sound like one of those end of the world/ conspiracy theorists. And your post about how you will never pay off your loan is bogus. Some people, especially ones that do co-op are able to pay off their loan even before they leave school, so stop flaming the boards with nonsense.


yeah its very easy to end up paying more than 100% of the original value of a house, car appliance and "major" purchases with your pathetic credit card, enjoy your life of being used (also you stringer). You guys will keep taking loans for fun and getting yourselfs raped by interest


Oh yeah, me and Stringer are the only two idiots in the world who believe credit has value. Man we must be living under a rock. You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if you default on a payment right? So pay your bills, and enjoy what you buy instead of wasting away half your paychecks in wasteless expenditure such as rent opposed to a mortgage, paying full price in cash instead of taking advantage of payment options etc.


Where to begin....roll eyes

"Actually getting manageable loans is not a bad idea."

Yes, yes it is a bad idea. Unless you like to give your hard earned money away.

"Buying a house, car, appliances, and other major purchases are made easier."

Anyone who buys any major purchase other than a house on credit is setting themselves up for financial ruin.

"You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if your default on a payment right?"

No, no it doesn't. On most things interest starts the day after your next payment is due if you still have a balance owing. And on a lot of loans interest is factored into your monthly payments to begin with.

"Wasting away half your paychecks in wasteless expenditure such as rent opposed to a mortgage, paying full price in cash instead of taking advantage or payment options"

You are aware that a lot of stores give a discount for people that pay with cash right? They just don't advertise it. Stores lose money when people use credit cards(unless it is their own store credit card). Also, there are many other advantages to saving up and paying with cash rather than credit or "payment plans".

Example:

You want to buy a a nice big lcd t.v. worth $2000.00 and you have nothing in the bank to put towards it and can only afford 84.00/month to go towards the t.v., whether you save up for it or put it on credit. If you put it on credit you estimate it will take 2 years to pay it off in full. And your credit card charges 18.5% annual interest.

Now, you have a decision, either save up the money for that t.v. or put it on credit. Lets look at how that works out in the long run for each option.

Cash option:


You put $84.00/month into a term savings account earning 3.3% interest compounded daily and paid monthly you would have $1997.06 in your account for the tv after 2 years. Where $65.06 is interest EARNED. So you are actually only paying around $1935.00 for the t.v. And maybe much less depending on if the store offers a cash discount.

Credit option:


You take the plunge and put the t.v. on the credit card which charges 18.5% annual interest compounded monthly and you make $84.00/month payments until it is paid off. It will take you 30 months to pay off the balance, total amount paid $2511.35. That is $511.35 in interest. Now what if you decided to put the t.v. on a store credit card, lets say, FutureShop, which charges a disgusting 28.8% annual interest, while still making the $84.00/month payments, it would take you 36 months to pay off, total paid $3001.19, with $1001.19 in interest.

So...

Cash = $1935.00(or less) paid for a $2000.00 tv in two years.

Credit card at 18.5% = $2511.35 paid for a $2000.00 t.v.

Store credit card at 28.8% = $3001.19 paid for a $2000.00 t.v.

What else is there to say? lol..


So then why are my parents not drowning in debt, and finding it hard to make ends meet? They don't have lots of savings, or any extra money lying around. The reason is because they stay on top of their payments. Credit is not bad if you pay it off. I said that "You are aware that on most things, interest only starts accumulating if your default on a payment right?". You responded:
No, no it doesn't. On most things interest starts the day after your next payment is due if you still have a balance owing.
So like I was saying PAY your bills ON TIME, and you don't get charged interest. It's not that difficult a concept to understand, and obviously DON'T use a credit card or take credit if you know that you won't have the money by the time you need to make a payment.
Secondly, you misinterpreted my point on "Buying a house, car, appliances, and other major purchases are made easier.' I was referring to this as a benefit of building a credit rating, I wasn't talking about buying these items on a line of credit or credit card.
Lastly, I know I made a mistake about saying that it was better to take a payment option opposed to paying cash if possible, what can I say, wasn't thinking right, sorry.

UWO '12 Social Science
snapicus
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 3:23:20 PM
Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 4/15/2008
Posts: 4
Location: Nashville, TN USA
Quote:
They don't have lots of savings, or any extra money lying around.


Because a lot of their income is likely tied up in payments. I'm not dissing you or your parents, but the problem with a lot of families is that if one parent gets laid off or if some financial hardship comes along, it happens unexpectedly and the payments that were easy to make before are now a stretch, straining both the finances and the marriage.

Even if that doesn't happen, the average consumer is throwing away more money than they realize when they use credit. I would refer you again to the Dun & Bradstreet study that shows that people spend 12-18% more when they use credit than when they pay cash. McDonald's started accepting credit cards when they did their own study and found that the average ticket increased by 50% ("sure, lets Super Size it"). Vending machines are beginning to accept cards because the average purchase doubles! ("hmm...guess I'll get a coke to go with my chips"). Now carry that over to every purchase you make on credit. You get the larger TV, the extra options on the car, and suddenly your kids' college fund isn't getting fed and you're stuck paying that mortgage for the rest of your life.

I lived that way for years, but recently I've spent a lot of time looking into it and these are the conclusions that I've come to. I'm not trying to hammer you with it, but when you dont have a car payment and your house is paid off, you have so much more control over your destiny than when you're shackled to payments.
bigbadsheep
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 5:12:55 PM

Rank: Valedictorian
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 538
snapicus wrote:
Quote:
They don't have lots of savings, or any extra money lying around.


Because a lot of their income is likely tied up in payments. I'm not dissing you or your parents, but the problem with a lot of families is that if one parent gets laid off or if some financial hardship comes along, it happens unexpectedly and the payments that were easy to make before are now a stretch, straining both the finances and the marriage.

Even if that doesn't happen, the average consumer is throwing away more money than they realize when they use credit. I would refer you again to the Dun & Bradstreet study that shows that people spend 12-18% more when they use credit than when they pay cash. McDonald's started accepting credit cards when they did their own study and found that the average ticket increased by 50% ("sure, lets Super Size it"). Vending machines are beginning to accept cards because the average purchase doubles! ("hmm...guess I'll get a coke to go with my chips"). Now carry that over to every purchase you make on credit. You get the larger TV, the extra options on the car, and suddenly your kids' college fund isn't getting fed and you're stuck paying that mortgage for the rest of your life.

I lived that way for years, but recently I've spent a lot of time looking into it and these are the conclusions that I've come to. I'm not trying to hammer you with it, but when you dont have a car payment and your house is paid off, you have so much more control over your destiny than when you're shackled to payments.


Umm actually in my situation it's because they used their life savings to move my family out of a third world country so that we could have a better life for ourselves. They were successful back home, and as a result that would of made us targets for violence.

Good thing Canada recognizes immigrant's qualifications and doctor's,lawyers and other professionals don't need to start over from the bottom when they move here(major sarcasm in case you can't tell).

And I agree with what you are saying about how easy it is to be sucked into spending more with a credit card as opposed to being limited with cash in hand, but I have been taught to treat a credit card as cash in hand and not spend more than is required, which is what I have done so far. It's all a matter of self control, so to say all credit is bad because people can't control themselves is wrong.

UWO '12 Social Science
nasir jones
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 5:18:04 PM

Rank: Senior Student
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/10/2008
Posts: 264
snapicus wrote:

In the words of a great teacher, Dave Ramsey "Broke is normal. Be Wierd." smile



HAHAHHA I got my knowledge from Dave Ramsey too
Stringer
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 5:31:59 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 1,711
Location: Wilfrid Laurier University
bigbadsheep wrote:
Good thing Canada recognizes immigrant's qualifications and doctor's,lawyers and other professionals don't need to start over from the bottom when they move here(major sarcasm in case you can't tell).


Would you trust a doctor that was not educated up to Canadian standards? I wouldn't. We have different standards here and there is nothing wrong requiring everybody to abide by them. Also, things like lawyers and other professionals that are not accredited in Canada generally do not have the skills to work in those professions in Canada. What would a lawyer trained in Africa know about Canadian law?

-Stringer
bigbadsheep
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 6:07:37 PM

Rank: Valedictorian
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/4/2008
Posts: 538
Stringer wrote:
bigbadsheep wrote:
Good thing Canada recognizes immigrant's qualifications and doctor's,lawyers and other professionals don't need to start over from the bottom when they move here(major sarcasm in case you can't tell).


Would you trust a doctor that was not educated up to Canadian standards? I wouldn't. We have different standards here and there is nothing wrong requiring everybody to abide by them. Also, things like lawyers and other professionals that are not accredited in Canada generally do not have the skills to work in those professions in Canada. What would a lawyer trained in Africa know about Canadian law?


Actually yes I would. Most professionals, at least where I'm from, went away for schooling anyway, because at the time there was not an accredited university at home. Most professionals I've heard of,met, or known through my parents went away for school to universities in the UK, U.S. and Canada. They learnt what everyone else learnt, but because they chose to be licensed at home, and not in a country where they wouldn't be living (as yet) their qualifications are invalid? You could make the case about lawyers, but medicine and engineering is pretty standard across the board.
A doctor or engineer with foreign experience can bring a fresh, new look to a topic or problem.
How is medicine in Africa/ the Caribbean different from the U.S./Canada aside from availability of resources? Influenza, measles, chicken pox, all have the same symptoms throughout the world.

UWO '12 Social Science
Stringer
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 6:18:34 PM

Rank: Student Body President
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/5/2008
Posts: 1,711
Location: Wilfrid Laurier University
bigbadsheep wrote:
Stringer wrote:
bigbadsheep wrote:
Good thing Canada recognizes immigrant's qualifications and doctor's,lawyers and other professionals don't need to start over from the bottom when they move here(major sarcasm in case you can't tell).


Would you trust a doctor that was not educated up to Canadian standards? I wouldn't. We have different standards here and there is nothing wrong requiring everybody to abide by them. Also, things like lawyers and other professionals that are not accredited in Canada generally do not have the skills to work in those professions in Canada. What would a lawyer trained in Africa know about Canadian law?


Actually yes I would. Most professionals, at least where I'm from, went away for schooling anyway, because at the time there was not an accredited university at home. Most professionals I've heard of,met, or known through my parents went away for school to universities in the UK, U.S. and Canada. They learnt what everyone else learnt, but because they chose to be licensed at home, and not in a country where they wouldn't be living (as yet) their qualifications are invalid? You could make the case about lawyers, but medicine and engineering is pretty standard across the board.
A doctor or engineer with foreign experience can bring a fresh, new look to a topic or problem.
How is medicine in Africa/ the Caribbean different from the U.S./Canada aside from availability of resources? Influenza, measles, chicken pox, all have the same symptoms throughout the world.


They have different standards of training. Do you actually believe that the government of Canada is discriminating against immigrants by requiring them to get licensed in Canada?

-Stringer
LeaF
Posted: Tuesday, April 15, 2008 6:36:00 PM

Rank: Frosh
Groups: Member

Joined: 3/9/2008
Posts: 36
Location: Toronto,Ontario, Canada
I think in many ways discrimination is inadvertently created by of the grossly ineffective system (or lack thereof) of accreditation we have in this country. Yes, in some instances the standards of training are different. In some instances, they are more rigorous than our own (lets not get too caught up in ethnocentric notions of superiority).

I agree that sometimes the quality of foreign qualifications warrant consideration, but licensing procedures are unnecessarily difficult. It seems like a travesty to me that an experienced professional's entire academic and occupation life is discarded. There should be institutional mechanisms in place to allow them to upgrade their valuable skills without having to start from the very beginning, which is often too expensive for recent immigrants hence all the highly intelligent taxi drivers in Toronto. This is further pronounced in areas such as medicine, where we have a striking need for doctors, particularly in rural jurisdictions.

I don't see how our current procedures for recognizing (even in part) foreign qualifications can be seen as anything but an utter embarrassment.


H.B.A. (History) University of Toronto '08
M.A. (History) York University '09


Forum Jump

Powered by Yet Another Forum.net
Copyright © 2003-2006 Yet Another Forum.net. All rights reserved.
Copyright © 1998-2008 studentawards.com & boursetudes.com - Studentawards Inc. All rights reserved.